When you draw a structure in PCMODEL and save it in mopac format, PCMODEL writes a file with the atoms in a particular order, depending upon the bonding arrangement. The first atom listed is "atom 1", the second atom listed is "atom 2", etc. See the transition state example dat file. The line for each atom includes the following:
(atom type) (bond distance) (bond optimization flag)...
(angle) (angle optimization flag)...
(torsion angle) (torsion angle optimization flag)...
(atom # to which this atom is bonded)...
(atom # with which this atom makes an angle,
where the previous atom # is the angle vertex)...
(atom # with which this atom makes a torsion angle,
where the previous two atom #s are the vertices)...
(partial charge).
To calculate a transition state, the order of the atoms in the reactant and the product must be the same. However, the order in which PCMODEL lists the atoms in the mopac-style file MAY BE DIFFERENT for the reactant and product. To verify/change the order of the atoms so the reactant and product match: